Go to ...


RSS Feed

June 23, 2017

Positional Analysis: Guard

This is the seventh of a 14-part series examining each position going into the offseason.

Starters (D): Josh Sitton and T.J. Lang were the starting guards seven months ago. As of today, Lane Taylor and Don Barclay are atop the depth chart. That’s like going from Simon and Garfunkel to the Captain and Tennille. And while Taylor would up doing a decent job replacing Sitton last season, it won’t be as easy filling the void left by Lang’s exit to Detroit. Barclay is best suited to a backup role and there doesn’t appear to be any younger players ready to step up.

Depth (F): If the regular season started today – and thank God it doesn’t – Lucas Patrick would likely be the No. 3 guard. And while the former undrafted free agent from Duke did flash some intriguing potential last summer, having him be one turned ankle away from protecting Aaron Rodgers isn’t what anyone wants to see – especially Rodgers. Another young player to consider at the position is right tackle Kyle Murphy, who has the skill set to slide a few feet to his left. What the former sixth-round draft pick doesn’t have – at least right now – is the experience. He’s been a tackle since his freshman year at the University of Stanford. 

Player to watch: Patrick first came to my attention in the preseason opener last August. That’s because the then anonymous rookie was holding his own vs. the Browns. His solid work continued all summer – even with a broken hand that forced him to wear a club. Patrick has a similar skill set to Lang. He possesses decent size, plenty of toughness and just enough athleticism to get the job done. That said, counting on him to replace the All-Pro next season is probably unrealistic.

*Level of need: The O-line did just fine without Sitton, but that was because 80% of the unit was still comprised of Pro Bowl caliber players. The percentage will be down to 60% in 2017, so chances are the loss of Lang will be felt more. How much more will be determined by what Thompson does in the next few months. Whether through free agency or the draft, he needs to find a legit starter at right guard. Otherwise, what has been a strength for years could turn into a weakness.


Tags: , ,

4 Responses “Positional Analysis: Guard”

  1. Mark
    March 25, 2017 at 12:27 pm

    This is a depressing group of guards even for a GM who doesn’t value the position. There’s has to be a free agent out there who’s better than Barclay and Patrick, doesn’t there?

  2. TJV
    March 29, 2017 at 1:03 pm

    To date Thompson has left too many immediate needs to be filled in the draft, including of course the OL. If they had two established starting OGs, finding depth in the draft is a little risky, but nothing like going from two great OGs before releasing Sitton to having the weak link on last year’s OL the only starter at OG. Perhaps Kyle Murphy is up to the job at RG. Here’s what he said in an interview: “Obviously there’s a vacancy at the right guard position, and that’s a position that I was sprinkled in there throughout the season, especially in the middle and latter parts of the year, starting to get some reps in there and get my feet wet, get used to the feel for it because I’d never experienced playing inside before.” http://www.jsonline.com/story/sports/nfl/packers/2017/03/26/q-packers-kyle-murphy-could-take-bigger-role-offensive-line/99669530/

  3. Jon
    April 4, 2017 at 12:17 pm

    To suggest Bulaga failed at left tackle is completely untrue. He never got the chance to play there. Instead, he’s been a very good right tackle for years. That’s a pretty good return on a player picked in the bottom third of the first round.

  4. TJV
    April 4, 2017 at 1:25 pm

    Jon, I agree but I think your post was meant to be posted in “Spriggs Won’t Sit For Long”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *