Monday Musings: Backup QBs

It was embarrassing listening to Matt LaFleur plead with fans to stop chanting “Go Pack Go” and doing the wave while Green Bay is on offense. Either the people in the stands aren’t as sophisticated as they were in the past, or maybe it’s time to stop selling alcohol at Lambeau. Here are three more Packers-related thoughts that ran through my mind recently:

1) As I watched Kurk Benkert on Saturday, the image of Doug Pederson kept popping into my head. Not the Super Bowl-winning head coach, but the backup quarterback who played 10 seasons for Green Bay, Miami, Cleveland, and Philadelphia. It wouldn’t surprise me at all if Benkert has that type of career in the NFL. While more talented than Pederson, the fourth-year pro from Virginia isn’t good enough to be a starter, but he has all the intangibles teams look for in a No. 3 QB. He’s smart, prepared, and maybe most important of all, he seems to be well-liked by his teammates. One of the reasons Pederson lasted so long in Green Bay was his extremely close bond with Brett Favre. Benkert already appears to have a good relationship with Aaron Rodgers and Jordan Love. In fact, he might be the perfect person to have around in ’22 should Love take over the starting job. Whether Benkert is part of the final 53 is very much up in the air, but I fully expect him to be around the team in some capacity for the next few seasons.

2) It was only one play, but watching Corey Davis of the Jets beat Eric Stokes on an in route reminded me why I projected Green Bay’s No. 1 pick as a mid to late second-rounder. There’s no question the speedy cornerback has the skill set to be a starter at this level, but he’ll have to figure out a way to stay with quality wide receivers in the middle of the field if he’s going to be more than just a Kevin King-type player. Stokes has some tightness in his hips that affects his transitional quickness and leaves him vulnerable to certain routes. Plenty of college corners have overcome this weakness to become outstanding pros. Marlon Humphrey comes to mind immediately. But plenty of others wind up like King, or even worse, Josh Jackson. The Packers have missed on a lot of corners in the early rounds since 2015; it’s up to Stokes, coordinator Joe Barry, and secondary coach Jerry Gray to make sure this one works out.

Stokes’ tight hips aren’t the only problem on this particular play, but it’s one of the reasons he couldn’t cover Davis despite the 10-yard cushion

3) I can’t remember the GM who said it or even the sport for that matter, but I do remember the person’s exact words: “What the hell was the assistant doing while his boss was failing?” He asked that question while explaining to the media why he’d never promote an assistant to replace a fired coach? It’s really hard to argue with that way of thinking, and yet Green Bay keeps promoting the assistant to every failed special teams coordinator. It didn’t work when Shawn Slocum replaced Mike Stock in 2009 or when Ron Zook replaced Slocum in 2015. Maurice Drayton, who spent the past two seasons under Shawn Mennenga, will try to break that disturbing trend. Based on the past couple of weeks, he has work to do. The Packers gave up long returns against both Houston and the Jets.

Please make a small donation if you appreciate this type of content ⬇️

This poll is no longer accepting votes

POLL: Which veteran is most in danger of being released?

Visits: 1931 Today: 2


  1. It’s crazy how much Benkert reminds me of Don Makjowski. The number, the body, the way he plays. I don’t think he’s as good as Majik but the similarities are uncanny.

    Also, I love this site! Thank you Michael for giving me a place to go to get honest and good opinions on my favorite team.

  2. I’m excited to watch more of Stokes. Not sure how you keep him off the field.

    I echo the previous comment. Thanks for the posts!

  3. I guess beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. When I see Kurt Benkert I see neither Doug Peterson or Don Makjowski. But rather Joe Callahan. Those guys are meant for the practice squad. Could he could be Love’s non threatening back up next year? I suppose. But I’d rather see them keep 7 WR’s than 3 QB this year. Would you release Malik Taylor to keep Kurt Benkert? I certainly would not.

    As far as Stokes, CB by their very nature get beat. Especially rookies. Stokes will be no exception. We haven’t see anyone with his speed since Sam Shields and Davante Adams said as much. Hopefully we can get him up to speed before Kevin King has his annual injury. I’m more worried about Jean-Charles than Stokes. I haven’t been overly impressed by what I’ve seen so far.

  4. Really interesting to read this take just after reading JSOnline’s take on Stokes, with them basically saying other than that one play, Stokes looked good and is in the top 3 of their corners. One thing I will say is that I assume Barry will be calling a lot more press, since that is what LaFleur seems to be prefer and seems to work best with Stokes’ speed.

    Good to hear about Newman. Hopefully he’ll fit in the Packer tradition of last decade and a half of finding really solid, impressive OL in the 4th round.

    Was glad to see Barnes and Keke pop in limited snaps, from what I saw.

    As for the players that are going to be cut and hopefully make the practice squad – this looks like the best practice squad we’ve seen in a long time.

    Curious what you saw in McDuffie. Was his play responsible for Martin’s release?

    Does Njiman’s play put Van Lanen on PS and put Kelly at risk?

    • I saw McDuffie make a few tackles, but honestly, I didn’t pay a lot of attention to him. I’ll try to focus on him this week.

      I’ll do my next roster projection on Wednesday. There are going to be a lot of tough decisions at the bottom of the roster.

  5. I give LaFleur a pass on Pettine and Mennenga, but Barry and Drayton are 100% his guys. He needs to be right about both of them.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Packers Notes is the creation of Michael Rodney, who has been writing about the Green Bay Packers for over 30 years. His first blog, Packer Update, hit the internet in 2004. Before becoming a public educator, Rodney worked as a journalist for a couple of newspapers in his home state of New Jersey and covered the Philadelphia Eagles for WTXF-TV. He's had numerous articles on the Packers published, and he's been featured on both television and radio over the years.
2 visitors online now
2 guests, 0 members